10 Best Performances In Robert Eggers Movies, Ranked

Widely regarded as one of the most talented and inimitable filmmakers currently plying their trade in the genre,Robert Eggers has forged a reputation for himself as one of the best modern horror directors in the space of little under a decade. Beginning with his feature film directorial debut in 2015's The Witch,Eggers' quartet of historical movies has received critical acclaim, seamlessly blending elements of various genres while placing a heavy emphasis on horror and folklore. The director's latest movie, a lauded adaptation of 1922's Nosferatu, has proved no exception to this trend.

However, all the celebrated filmmaker's success would never have been possible without an array of stunning performances from the men and women charged with bringing his characters and premises to life onscreen, from frequent artistic collaborators to one-and-done wonders and newer cast additions. The best performances in Robert Eggers' movies can be found scattered relatively evenly throughout his filmography to date, featuring knockout bows from some of the most talented and beloved faces that Hollywood has to offer.

10 Aaron Taylor-Johnson As Friedrich Harding

Nosferatu (2024)

Friedrich Harding (Aaron Taylor-Johnson) in Nosferatu

Taking on a role in a Robert Eggers movie for the first time in 2024's Nosferatu, Kraven the Hunter star Aaron Taylor-Johnson was charged with bringing supporting character Friedrich Harding to life. Based on the Dracula character, Arthur Holmwood, the actor's charge meets a decidedly more tragic fate than his literary counterpart. A grief-stricken Harding dies of the plague after Count Orlok murders his entire family, with the heavy intimation that he committed necrophilia with his wife's corpse resulting in one of Nosferatu's most shocking scenes.

While Taylor-Johnson struggles to escape the constraints of a notably underwritten role, the actor does his best with what he has to work with. The Kick-Ass alum's efforts may come across as slightly hammy in patches, but he still does a commendable job of capturing Friedrich's haughty pomposity and sense of incredulous disbelief at the supernatural events unfolding before his eyes. Taylor-Johnson also lends heartbreaking authenticity to the inconsolable grief that takes Friedrich following the loss of his family, bringing the tale of one of the movie's more tragic characters full circle.

9 Anya Taylor-Joy As Olga

The Northman (2022)

The Queen's Gambit star Anya Taylor-Joy has always found her name inextricably linked with that of Robert Eggers since her breakout role in 2015's The Witch, the movie that incidentally also served as the director's introduction to mainstream pop-culture. The actress' second collaboration with Eggers saw Taylor-Joy play the role of Olga in 2022's historical action epic The Northman, a Slavic sorceress and the love interest of Alexander Skårsgard's titular character.

Anya Taylor-Joy was originally slated to appear in 2024's Nosferatu, before eventually being replaced with Lily-Rose Depp.

The Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga star is known for her exceptionally nuanced performances at this point in proceedings, and Taylor-Joy doesn't disappoint with another mesmerizing bow here. Olga and Amleth's romance serves as one of the movie's most compelling elements, a remarkable status quo given the vast gap in ages between the two real-life performers, that is due in no small part to the committed efforts of the American actress. Lending determination and mystique to her latest Eggers production bow in equal measure, Taylor-Joy's next collaboration with the director is sure to be one to watch.

8 Willem Dafoe As Professor Albin Eberhart Von Franz

Nosferatu (2024)

Returning for his third Robert Eggers movie in a row, Willem Dafoe steps into the boots of the magnificently mustachioed Professor Albin Eberhart von Franz in 2024's box-office smash-hit Nosferatu. The film's equivalent of Dracula's legendary vampire hunter, Professor Abraham Van Helsing, a significant part of what makes Dafoe's performance in Nosferatu so superb is the barely disguised joy that the established A-Lister is clearly taking in his latest bow.

Willem Dafoe received one of his four Academy Award nominations for his work in another vampire-based movie, 2000's Shadow of the Vampire.

A disgraced former professor and current occult expert brought in to examine Ellen Hutter, Dafoe's endlessly watchable charge lurches between logical and maniacal at the drop of a hat. Von Franz is the best mad scientist character that cinema has seen in years, with the actor lending a unique brand of chaotic energy to proceedings that steal the show in every scene he appears in. In particular, the image of a cackling Von Franz against the backdrop of Orlok's burning crypt already has the makings of an iconic horror snapshot.

7 Alexander Skarsgård As Amleth

The Northman (2022)

The leading man of Robert Eggers' first action movie, 2022's The Northman, Alexander Skarsgård absolutely killed it in his take on the eponymous character. Based on the Scandinavian legend of Amleth,the movie sees the True Blood alum play a Viking prince on a brutal quest to avenge his father. Skarsgård completely loses himself in his performance here, producing a devastating depiction of merciless retribution that is often jarringly juxtaposed against a surprising degree of vulnerability for such a terrifying warrior.

Leveraging his excellent chemistry with co-star Anya Taylor-Joy to maximum effect, Skarsgård's first collaboration with Eggers sees him turn in what is contentiously a career-best performance. Carrying this blood-soaked tale of vengeance through his formidable onscreen presence, the Swedish actor also plays off his primary onscreen adversary, Claes Bang's Fjölnir, in textbook fashion to lend primal authenticity to this fictional mortal enmity.

6 Bill Skarsgård As Count Orlok

Nosferatu (2024)

It seems mildly ironic that, despite taking on the role of the titular, and purportedly main, character in 2024's Nosferatu, It star Bill Skarsgård doesn't actually turn in the movie's best performance. This is due in large part to the nature of his character's role in Robert Eggers' acclaimed horror movie. Count Orlok's full appearance is only slowly unveiled throughout the movie and is nearly always shrouded in darkness, while Skarsgård is also buried in enough prosthetics to conceal a missing head.

Accordingly, it speaks volumes to the quality of the Swedish actor's performance that he still turns in a memorable bow; Skarsgård's co-stars were allegedly terrified of him on-set. However, the most impressive aspect of the Barbarian star's performance is undoubtedly the voice he imbues Orlok with. Deftly sidestepping any potential comedic pitfalls associated with his character's old-time style cadence, Skarsgård's ominously booming delivery is pitch perfect, from his accent down to the very tone of his voice.

5 Anya Taylor-Joy As Thomasin

The Witch (2015)

Anya Taylor-Joy as Thomasin standing in the woods in The Witch — Anya Taylor-Joy as Thomasin in The Witch

Serving as the breakout moment for one of Hollywood's most prominent current A-Listers, Anya Taylor-Joy's first major role in 2015's The Witch marked the actress out as a name to watch moving forward. The Menu star plays Thomasin against the backdrop of Robert Eggers' feature film debut, a young Puritan woman who goes on to become a witch after a series of malevolent supernatural occurrences plague her family.

Widely regarded as one of the best horror movies of the 2010s, The Witch's enviable status as such is due in no small part to Taylor-Joy's impressive efforts. The actress captures the considerable nuances of the coming-of-age transformation at the heart of Eggers' movie in masterful style, a state of affairs that is all the more remarkable considering that this was her feature film debut.

4 Nicholas Hoult As Thomas Hutter

Nosferatu (2024)

Nicholas Hoult has come a long way since his days on Skins. Following in his recent vein of vampire-themed movies after his bow as the titular character in 2023's Renfield, the Englishman was cast as Thomas Hutter in 2024's Nosferatu, a role that allegedly saw Hoult nearly attacked by wolves during filming. Based on Bram Stoker's iconic character Jonathan Harker, Hoult took to his new charge like a duck to water, turning in a performance that captures the essence of his confusing and conflicting relationship with his wife Ellen in heartbreaking style.

...Hoult's performance lends an air of near-feral desperation to his charge that results in one of the most powerful horror bows in recent memory.

Determined to help his beloved, but rendered powerless by not knowing how to act, Hoult's performance lends an air of near-feral desperation to his charge that results in one of the most powerful horror bows in recent memory. The Englishman is also notably excellent in his early scenes with Bill Skarsgård's Count Orlok, producing a harrowing snapshot of the visceral terror associated with being confronted by such a terrifying being.

3 Willem Dafoe As Thomas Wake

The Lighthouse (2019)

Willem Dafoe looking mischevious in The Lighthouse

Widely regarded as one of the most influential movies of the 2010s, Robert Eggers' The Lighthouse walks the lines between various genres without ever quite deciding which camp to ultimately land in. Depicting two lighthouse keepers marooned in the titular structure and their subsequent descent into madness, the movie is carried by a pair of powerhouse performances from Willem Dafoe and Robert Pattinson.

Willem Dafoe & Robert Eggers' Collaborations
Movie	Role
The Lighthouse (2019)	Thomas Wake
The Northman (2022)	Heimir the Fool
Nosferatu (2024)	Professor Albin Eberhart von Franz

Dafoe is in sparkling form against the backdrop of his first Eggers movie as the aging Thomas Wake, a hobbled former able-seaman and the more senior of the two lighthouse keepers. There's something almost Shakespearean about the actor's masterful take on Wake, capturing every nuance of the pair's time isolated together in a manner that lurches between darkly humorous and completely disturbing with little to no warning. It's one of the Platoon star's most impressive roles, an acclaimed performance that also happens to feature one of Dafoe's most gruesome movie deaths.

2 Robert Pattinson As Ephraim Winslow / Thomas Howard

The Lighthouse (2019)

Willem Dafoe turns in an exemplary performance as Thomas Wake in 2019's The Lighthouse, a state of affairs that says a lot about the masterful quality of his co-star Robert Pattinson's performance, considering that The Batman star ultimately ends up overshadowing him. Pattinson is absolutely magnificent in his sole Eggers movie appearance to date as "Ephraim Winslow," a lighthouse keeper later revealed to be an impostor by the name of Thomas Wake.

The Twilight alum brings every aspect of Winslow's surreal slide into madness to life with a performance that relentlessly builds in intensity across 109 mind-bending minutes. The actor effortlessly chronicles his character's jarring transformation from a grim and taciturn man with a sullen disposition at the movie's outset to an unraveled individual consumed with nail-biting paranoia and uncertainty by the end. The Lighthouse represents a career-best movie performance for Pattinson, and is one of the most impressive pieces of dramatic work in recent memory.

1 Lily-Rose Depp As Ellen Hutter

Nosferatu (2024)

The pressure was decidedly on Lily-Rose Depp to deliver in her role as Ellen Hutter in 2024's Nosferatu. Not only was it the young actress' first leading role in a major blockbuster, but frequent Robert Eggers collaborator Anya Taylor-Joy had also originally been attached to the role. The decision to replace the established actress with Depp was met with considerable backlash from some fans, with many decrying Depp's lack of experience and igniting the nepo-baby debate once again.

Of course, that was until Nosferatu debuted and Depp proceeded to blow her critics out of the water with a bow for the ages. Producing the best performance in a Robert Eggers movie to date, the Wolf star is mesmerizing in her take on Count Orlok's prey, Ellen Hutter, capturing every impassioned nuance of this tortured soul with unflinching clarity. Drawing inspiration from 1981's Possession, Depp is also particularly impressive in the sequences depicting paranormal occurrences, producing a notably harrowing depiction of Ellen's supernatural seizures that lingers in the mind's eye long after the credits roll.

trendglee