Why Netflix's Controversial Murder Mystery Series Is Accurate About Jeffrey Dahmer Story Explained By Expert

Netflix's controversial Dahmer – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story has been rated as highly accurate in its depiction of the infamous serial "Milwaukee Cannibal" killer by a crime expert. Created by American Horror Story's Ryan Murphy, the miniseries stars Evan Peters as the titular killer. One of the most-watched series on Netflix, Dahmer offered a dramatized peek into the killer's life, including his eventual capture, while portraying some of the systemic failures that allowed Dahmer to evade justice for years. Despite its popularity, Dahmer has sparked controversy among families of the victims for sensationalizing the tragedies and potentially retraumatizing them.

On Insider’sHow Real Is It? series, former homicide detective Pat Postiglione assesses the depiction of Dahmer's crimes in the true crime show, rating it a perfect 10 out of 10 for realism. He specifically reviewed a scene of Dahmer in which detectives search the killer's apartment and find a collection of bones in his bedroom and body parts in his freezer. Here's what he had to say:

In some cases, [Dahmer] would keep the bodies, he would behead them, he would keep body parts inside of his refrigerator, and apparently had been, at some point, possibly even eating some of his victims, and really just beyond the imagination, couldn’t even think of, he was involved in. It appears to be an accurate depiction of Jeffery Dahmer’s crimes and also how they approached the crime scene.
They were doing the same thing. They were in the suspect’s apartment, but at the same time, it was also the ‘killing field’ where he was killing a lot of his victims. So it was kind of a two-fold thing. Suspect lived here. He also did some of his killings here.

Postiglione’s breakdown of the Dahmer scene not only validates the authenticity of the series but reflects the sheer horror of Dahmer’s crimes. As investigators came upon bones, frozen hearts, and vats of unmarked chemicals, the detective said the following:

When you find just bones, it’s a little more difficult. You hope to find some marking on the bones that’ll indicate a gunshot wound, indicate a strike mark, a stab wound, or anything along those lines. It’s more difficult when you find just bones. But when you find bones in someone’s refrigerator or a bunch of bones inside of a vat full of some sort of a chemical you can be rest assured that that victim was murdered.

Ultimately, Postiglione gave this scene from Ryan Murphy's crime miniseries a perfect score, saying:

It looks like something that we would’ve done pretty much the same way they were doing it in detail, great detail.

What The Accuracy Of Netflix's Dahmer Means

Murphy's Saga Realistically Captured The Crimes

What set Dahmer apart from other true crime series was its laser-sharp focus on systemic racism within the Milwaukee Police Department, which allowed Dahmer, a white, blue-eyed man, to repeatedly evade suspicion and continue preying on primarily Black and queer victims. By emphasizing certain moments in key episodes—such as officers leaving Tony Hughes in Dahmer’s custody—the series highlighted how institutional bias gave Dahmer ample opportunity to murder so many Black and brown men as a broader critique of American policing and societal injustice.

While Dahmer does not shy away from Jeffrey Dahmer’s gruesome crimes with haunting accuracy, it omits certain aspects of his childhood and his infamous apartment. Murphy had aimed to center the experiences of victims and survivors rather than solely focus on Dahmer’s life. Despite this intention, the series faced significant backlash, with some family members of Dahmer’s victims criticizing Netflix for not consulting them beforehand or compensating them. True crime dramas often walk a fine line between shedding light on injustice and retraumatizing those directly affected by the crimes, where their pain becomes the center of entertainment.

Our Take On Netflix’s Dahmer Accuracy

True Crime Storytelling Walks A Fine Line

Monster: the Jeffrey Dahmer Story Evan Peters as Jeffrey Dahmer — Evan Peters as Jeffrey Dahmer in Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story

The public’s fascination with true crime often lies in the desire to understand the worst parts of humanity. While dramatized accounts like Dahmer – Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story can offer an accurate portrayal of the killer, they can also inadvertently glamorize someone like Dahmer or retraumatize survivors they set out to empower in the first place. Dramatized series—no matter how accurate—risk prioritizing shock value over genuine storytelling, especially when families of victims and survivors aren't consulted nor compensated. With another season of Monsters on its way, Murphy has hopefully learned to tread carefully.

Source: Insider/YouTube