Why Robin Williams (& Others) Refused The Mark Twain Prize Explained

The Mark Twain Prize for American Humor is one of the highest honors in American art and culture. Presented by the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts in Washington, D.C., the Mark Twain Prize honors those who have an impact similar to the 19th century American author, Samuel Clemens, aka Mark Twain. The winner has the opportunity to meet the current president. It's worth mentioning that the award is mostly awarded to America's best comedic minds, despite Twain's writings not aligning with what people think is comedy today.

But, technicalities aside, a number of would-be winners have refused the prize. Notably, the late Robin Williams refused the award. While it's not completely clear why everyone who's turned it down chose not to be honored, the Twain Prize has arguably suffered some bad publicity, and, at the very least, isn't considered as prestigious as in the past. With the award ceremony now airing on Netflix, it's worth wondering if the Twain Prize is as meaningful today as it was when it was first presented in 1998.

It's Unknown Why Robin Williams Refused The Mark Twain Prize — & He's Not The Only One

Several Comedians Have Passed On The Award

Robin Williams refused the Mark Twain Prize back in 2009 for unknown reasons. However, Williams did attend the ceremony to honor winner Billy Crystal in 2007. There's speculation that Williams didn't accept the award because of his complex relationship with being awarded. Williams reportedly preferred to interact with fans more than be honored with an award.

The late comedian is also not the only one to refuse the award, as comedy legend Mel Brooks has said no to the honor three times. The co-founder of the Mark Twain Prize for American Humor, Cappy McGarr, spoke to Brooks' triple refusal (via WTOP News):

Mel Brooks has turned us down three times. The white whale that got away. … I said, ‘Look, Mel, if you say no, I’m gonna have to do a [‘Blazing Saddles’] No. 6 on you.’ … He laughed so hard I think I got some egg salad sandwich on my coat. … Mel Brooks is truly one of the people that 100% deserves the Mark Twain Prize.

After Williams refused the award, the honor went to the now-disgraced Bill Cosby. While Cosby was awarded the prize in 2009, The Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts rescinded his award back in 2018, after he was found guilty of indecent aggravated assault. Cosby had refused the award two times before because he was disappointed with the use of profanity in Richard Pyor's inaugural award in 1998 (via New York Times).

The Kevin Hart & Netflix Mark Twain Prize Controversy Explained

Hart's Deal With Netflix Raised Some Eyebrows Over Him Winning The Prize

Since 2024, the Mark Twain Prize presentation has been shown on Netflix. Before that, the ceremony was broadcast on PBS for over 20 years. Some critics argue that presenting the award on Netflix isolates American viewers who might not have access to streaming but still want to watch a significant moment in American art.

Related

All The Rock & Kevin Hart Movies, Ranked Worst To Best

Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson and Kevin Hart have become an unlikely comic double act in recent years, and here's their movies ranked worst to best.

Posts

The first comedian honored since Netflix took over the Mark Twain Prize was Kevin Hart in 2024, which caused controversy because of Hart's connection with the streaming service. In 2021, Hart signed a four-picture deal with Netflix, similar to Adam Sandler's deal with the streaming giant back in 2014, before Netflix was a staple in nearly every American home (via Fox Business).

Some also felt that Hart's win presents not just a conflict of interest, but also an indication that the Mark Twain Prize has lost its prestige. While Hart is certainly a talented comedian, he hasn't achieved icon status like so many other recipients, such as Bob Newhart, Carol Burnett, and Eddie Murphy. Plus, since its inception, the award has only been given to five women. Factor in Hart’s deal with Netflix, and the award is ripe for criticism about its merit.

Conan O'Brien Will Receive The 2025 Mark Twain Prize

He's Also Hosting The Oscars In March

Comedian and former late-night host Conan O'Brien is set to receive the 26th Mark Twain Prize. Former president of the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, Deborah F. Rutter, spoke highly of O'Brien on the foundation's website. She said: “For four decades, Conan O’Brien, has brought his unique blend of the smart, silly, insightful, and hilarious into our homes." (via John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts).

O'Brien is of course best known for hosting late-night talk shows like Late Night with Conan O'Brien and writing for classic comedy shows like Saturday Night Live and The Simpsons.On being honored with the Mark Twain Prize, O'Brien said, “I am honored to be the first winner of the Mark Twain Prize, recognized not for humor, but for my work as a riverboat pilot."

Conan O'Brien certainly has his hands full, as he is set to host the 97th Academy Awards on Sunday, March 2nd. The Mark Twain Prize ceremony will take place on Sunday, March 23rd. Netflix has yet to announce when the event will be streamed on its platform.